Proof – (1.Way)
1. Way: Causes are doing everything. (Positivism)
We shall mention only three of its numerous impossibilities:
First Impossibility:
Imagine there is a pharmacy in which there are
hundreds of jars and phials filled with quite different substances. A
living potion and a living remedy are required from those medicaments.
So we go to the pharmacy and see that they are to be found there in
abundance, yet in great variety. We examine each of the potions and see
that the ingredients have been taken in varying but precise amounts from
each of the jars and phials, one ounce from this, three from that, seven
from the next, and so on. If one ounce too much or too little had been
taken, the potion would not have been living and would not have
displayed its special quality. Next, we study the living remedy. Again,
the ingredients have been taken from the jars in a particular measure so
that if even the most minute amount too much or too little had been
taken, the remedy would have lost its special property.
Now, although the jars number more than fifty, the
ingredients have been taken from each according to measures and amounts
that are all different. Is it in any way possible or probable that the
phials and jars should have been knocked over by a strange coincidence
or sudden gust of wind and that only the precise, though different,
amounts that had been taken from each of them should have been spilt,
and then arranged themselves and come together to form the remedy? Is
there anything more superstitious, impossible and absurd than this?
Similarly, each living being may be likened to the
living potion in the comparison, and each plant to a living remedy. For
they are composed of matter that has been taken in most precise measure
from truly numerous and truly various substances. If these are
attributed to causes and the elements and it is claimed, “Causes created
these,” it is unreasonable, impossible and absurd a hundred times over,
just as it was to claim that the potion in the pharmacy came into
existence through the phials being knocked over; by accident.
I n S h o r t : The vital substances in this vast
pharmacy of the universe, which are measured on the scales of Divine
Determining and Decree of the All-Wise and Pre-Eternal One, can only
come into existence through a boundless wisdom, infinite knowledge and
all-encompassing will. The unfortunate person who declares that they are
the work of blind, deaf and innumerable elements and causes and natures,
which stream like floods; and the foolish, delirious person who claims
that that wondrous remedy poured itself out when the phials were knocked
over and formed itself, are certainly unreasonable and nonsensical.
Indeed, such denial and unbelief is a senseless absurdity.
Everybody knows that
there are a number of necessary conditions for occurrence of a potion;
1. Substances: It is essential that the
substances have to be present and ready.
2. Laboratory: A lab environment is needed
for such a precisive work, to protect the process against the effects of
external environment.
3. Formula: According to what these
ingredients will combine and constitute a potion? A need for a formula,
which requires information and knowledge, is obvious.
4. Pharmacist: Who is going to apply the
formula? What is it, that will bring the substances together in
appropriate amounts and order according to the formula? Isn’t it clear
that it cannot be done without a pharmacist?
So, while all of these requirements are
needed for the presence of a simple potion, how can we give these far
more complex and magnificent creatures and the universe into the hands
of blind, deaf, aimless causes?
Second Impossibility:
Everything in the
material realm is under restrictions of the laws of the material realm.
Accordingly, if the “cause” is material then it must be present inside
or near the “effect”. In other words, you have to touch it if you want
to compose something in the material realm. It doesn’t happen with
remotely controlled hocuspocus. For instance, if a table is material, it
means that the maker made it right next to it.
Since the causes are under restrictions of material
laws of this world, they need to be inside or near the thing to create
it. Let’s say an ant will be created. Which causes are needed to create
it? The elements (Na, Ca, Mg, N, C, H, O), sun, soil, air,water… All
of these must work and move in full alliance in the body of the ant. The
otherwise is not possible in material world, if we give the creation of
the ant to the causes. A phosphorus atom used in the eyes of the ant
must be put there by the soil itself. If something from the sun is
necessary, the sun needs to put it there in person. Ten thousand cells
of an ant cannot reach even the size of a pinhead. How does it possible
that this much causes enter and work in such a small area?
Let’s look at the issue in another
perspective. Gathering together of all the elements that make up the
ant’s body in perfect order, measure and full alliance for the sake of a
goal is a very big issue all on its own. But what is perfect order and
measure? An atom is in order in two respects; 1. In itself, with its
protons, neutrons and electrons, tremendous work in harmony. 2. Order
and harmony in relations with other atoms. Then, at an outer circle, a
cell’s own order in itself (which is made up of atoms) and accommodation
between the cells. In the next outer circle an organ’s own order in
itself (which is made up of cells) and harmony between the other organs
of the organism. Finished? Absolutely not. Shouldn’t we see the
relationship of this organism with the outside world? Can it be possible
to survive for an ant without proper hardware and equipment which will
provide compliance with all the laws and rules of the universe? So,
these facts should be considered when we talk about order, harmony and
balance.
Now, let us come to the
issue of alliance and goal. All the material reasons (Sun, air, soil,
water and element), which make up an ant, must have had an alliance for
this goal. Because we know that, there has to be an alliance in every
organized, systematic and harmonious thing. Think of an army that
the soldiers don’t obey the orders and they don’t work together for a
common purpose. Everybody moves on his own. There would be no need to
enemy to be defeated. Or think of a calcium atom. Is there any
intelligence, insight, knowledge, will or consciousness in it to
cooperate with a nitrogen atom for a common goal? One cannot explain it
with simple chemical laws. Because the laws can barely explain how but
not why.
So the point is; if a
mindless calcium atom is doing pretty smart jobs then it indicates us
the presence of an unseen mind. If the aimless earth is moving to a
purpose then it is an evidence of somebody behind, with a purpose.
To simplify this, I am going to give an example. Imagine a remotely
controlled toy car and put that in front of an ancient man. Then take
the remote and start to control the car from a hidden place. What is he
going to think when he sees the car moving by its own? It is stopping
when it comes to an obstacle and moving around without crashing. There
are to ways in front of our ancient man. Either he is going to think
that this thing is very smart, can see everywhere so it doesn’t crash,
has its own will, so it goes wherever it wants etc. Or he will get that
this lifeless, eyeless, mindless thing cannot do anything by its own. So
there has to be somebody around who sees everything to control it. Yes,
It’s that simple actually.
At first glance,
cause and effect seem very close to one another. But in fact, when you
look at carefully you will see that they are very far from each other.
Cow and milk, tree and apple appears to be tightly adherent. Is that so?
No need to tell the benefits of milk. Well, how can a cow produce it
while even if the whole human race together can’t. Does cow know human?
Does it know what we need to? Does it aware of the structure of our body
or our digestive system? No, it doesn’t. But there is an obvious milk
fact that fits the needs of us. So, it is essential the presence of one
behind, who knows our needs, our stomach and our body systems systems in
detail. Ok, forget that for a moment. Suppose that cow has got all
of mentioned attributes and talents. Now the question is; why would the
cow produce milk for the people while it never sees its benefit. Or why
would a tree drink mud and reserve the delicious apple for us? Do they
have compassion and love for us that we don’t know? If the answer is no,
then the obvious compassion in front of our eyes is coming from
somewhere else.
Third Impossibility:
If there is unity of
a being, then is has to be created by one hand. Let’s demonstrate
this sentence with an example. The command of a hundred soldiers by one
officer is a hundred times easier than the command of one soldier by a
hundred officers. What happens if one soldier is subordinated to a
hundred officers? Which officer’s orders wil he serve? It will be a
total mess. On the other hand commanding of thousands of soldiers by
the administration of a single commander is, as easy as commanding of
one soldier. Because everything has been leaded from one center and
everybody will obey to one order. Just like that, the unification of a
wide variety of causes for the presence of a single thing is much more
difficult than creation of many things by a single hand. Especially if
it is a living creature which has a perfect unity and a beautiful
harmony, then it completely refutes the theory of unification of
causes. Is it possible that all this harmony and order is given into
the hands of an infinite number of lifeless, ignorant, unconscious,
aggressive, blind and deaf causes. The sun wants to burn, the oceans
want to invade, the wind wants to sweep everything. None of them has
compassion, kindness, pity, measure, rule or consciousness. But despite
all these facts, neither there is a chaos nor even a single absurd or
nonsensical thing in the universe. What else can we account with this
fact, other than a single hand which rules everything?
At this point, let me
ask an interesting question. If we put all of these causes(the sun, air,
soil, water elements etc.) to one side and all the living things
(plants, animals, humans) to the other side, and if we ask to someone
who just came into the world that “which side do you think can create
the other side?”, what do you think the answer would be? How would you
answer? Which choice make sense? Of course you will say: “living things
which are more complex and advanced, make more sense to create the other
primitive side.” But we see that the opposite is happening. Vision is
being created by blind atoms, intelligence is coming from mindless
elements, consciousness from consciousless, life from lifeless… Yes,
this is what we are facing today which is presented in the name of
science. Yet, even if all the material causes and elements is put
together in the most advanced laboratories, with the power of all
humanity using the last technology for the sake of this purpose, it is
impossible to give life to a small artificial cell. How can we explain
this now?
Let’s look at the issue from a different angle.
While the “thing” gets more complex, the number of the causes which
are thought to be responsible for it increases. In parallel the
impossibility will be reinforced. For example imagine that we are trying
to organize a task with a team of blind people. The more the number of
people, the harder the task to be accomplished. What if these people are
also deaf and dumb. Is it possible to do a task with these people who
are unaware of each other? Now increase the number of them. That is the
situation, why the word of “chaos” is stands for. Well then, how come
blind, deaf, dumb and mindless causes creates a being which shows a
great harmony and order within its complexity?
Here is another example; different elements in
foods we eat, where do they know where to go in the body? Did they enter
the human body before? Do they know the systems of it? Why does the
calcium go into the bone but phosphorus go to the eye? Guess what would
happen if one of them lost the way. To which mindless cause do we give
this perfect job which requires infinite knowledge and wisdom?
So far, we have talked about and proved that material causes
are not able to create this material realm. What about the soul and
spirit that the hands of material causes can never reach and touch?
Whereas, that world is ten times more complex and wonderful than the
material world. Compassion, thinking, pride, arrogance, embarrassment,
sadness, joy, pleasure, conscience, will … How did all these come
into being? The sun has nothing to do with my compassion. How could air
be responsible from my embarrassment. Have you ever heard of such a
thing that the source of arrogance is nitrogen element? Can you imagine
that your willpower is coming from a piece of meat?
So, connecting all the universe and
everything in it to causes requires to accept all of these
impossibilities and ravings. You must be blind to say that a blind sees.
Only ignorance can attribute wisdom to an ignorant. We have nothing to
say for such ignorant and blind people, our words are for the people
who seek only the truth.
Now, before closing this “causes issue” let me
mention a probable question that likely to come to mind:
If the causes have no effect on anything and if
they cannot be the creator, then why do they exist? Why, even the
smallest tasks, must be connected to a cause?
Because this is not our main concern, I think it
will be enough if I give two reasons among many others:
God has placed apparent causes there as veils to
cover his hand of power. Because of mighty, honor and greatness, the
causes were created as a screen to God in two ways:
1. For example, a sultan sends a gift to someone. But he sends
it with a herald or a carrier. He does not take it to the man
personally. Because sultanate and mighty requires so. But the man who
takes the gift thanks to sultan not to the carrier. If he ignores or
forgets the sultan and kisses the carrier’s hands, everyone gets that
how foolish he is. Just as in this example God has made the causes as a
screen. Those servants, carriers and instruments exist in order to keep
and show the mighty and grandeur of the sultan. In other words, they
exist to hide the contact between the grandness and small or worthless
jobs. But we all know that the real action behind the curtain belongs to
himself.
2. The causes are created in order to prevent the unfair
complaints and wrong objections turn to the God. So they exist to be a
target plate. For example diseases are veils to death, so the people
who can not see the wisdom and beauty behind the death, will not impute
God for this. What do we always say to deaths? “He died of cancer, he
was shot, road accident etc”. So in fact they are all simple causes and
veils. It is God who gives life and death and does all the activities we
see around.
2. Way (It forms
itself)